Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dr David Pilgrim's avatar

As with his last piece, this author spoils a good argument with unsubstantiated ad hominem attributions. How does he know that Fonargy (who I do not know and have no brief for) has influenced the Royal College of Psychiatrists and British Psychological Society? As an activist involved with BPSWatch.com (you can see it online) I know for more tha author about the BPS and its dangerous guidance on gender. From the knowledge, key transgender players from the BPS have been involved with trans=capturing the organisation (and many others). I am fairly certain that Peter Fonargy is not one of those players. He may want to consult his lawyers about unfounded claims.

Expand full comment
Dr David Pilgrim's avatar

Until this author drops his scatter gun personalised attacks (such this one on me for raising the one he was making about Fonagy, who I do not know) I would urge the editor not to dignify his opinion pieces anymore. Ad hominem logic does not take any of us very far in serious debate; otherwise Savage Minds will degnerate into a version of Facebook in my view..

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts